No announcement yet.

The Way It Should Have Ended (6/11)

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Way It Should Have Ended (6/11)

    You folks know that I've followed the Sopranos on HBO semi-religiously since the show's premier. So, I was anxious for what the series finale might bring. The Sopranos fans knew there would be a twist, and we knew people would die. But, I personally was hoping the twist ending would be a bit more significant, and MORE people would die. What we got was the typical mid-season story progression with no real oomph. It was situation usual and nothing really happened. And, that was the point.

    So why pick on AJ specifically? Well, Robert Iler, can act his ass off. The problem is that I really didn't like what the producers did with the character. And the Carmela thing, I honestly thought she was going to shoot Tony a few seasons ago.

    Anyway, don't get me wrong, I like that it ended the way it did. But, I probably would have liked it if it had ended another way as well... especially if someone had shot AJ.

  • #2
    I am usually disappointed in series finales in general. I don't know, it always seems weird when things are resolved when the whole point of the show was that things weren't resolved...or they do the situation usual thing and it just doesn't work for a final episode.


    • #3
      yep it kinda went out with a fizzle... i was hoping for bloodbath myself so there was some finality to the series. not the life goes on ending.

      or other senario:
      The shrink should have turned states evidence and the FBI should have been rounding everyone up in one big sequence.
      "Are you classified an HUMAN?? Negative, Im a meat popsicle!!"


      • #4
        I actually haven't watched an episode this season, but I was looking forward to reading how it all ended. Conveniently there was a news article on the Comcast main page minutes after the finale finished airing. I like shows that end on that kind of note, but only if there is some significance for it to end in that manner. From what I've heard of the final scene, David Chase did a great job.

        XBL Gamertag - DarkXan


        • #5
          Originally posted by Tallika
          The shrink should have turned states evidence and the FBI should have been rounding everyone up in one big sequence.
          The shrink can't. Any evidence provided by the shrink would have been inadmissible in court due to patient/doctor priviledge. There are exceptions to the rule (in the Menendez Brothers murder trial in California, priviledge was ignored when one brother threatened the shrink that the other brother was visiting), but by and large anything you say to your shrink is off-limits for a prosecutor. Same thing with lawyers. And spouses can't be compelled to testify (though unlike shrinks and lawyers, they have the option to do so if they choose).


          • #6
            Simultaneously across America, millions thought their cable box dropped signal. I know I did.

            I was very pissed at the time, but I have to say now that the ending was better than anything else I could contemplate. Tony dies = cliche. Tony goes into witness protection = cliche. David Chase's series was about being everything but cliche. Can't say my 8 years watching was wasted.


            • #7
              LOL um...ok...can't say I've ever been a fan of The Sopranos, but cool comic.

              There is, however, a new series on Shotime now called The Tudors that I find utterly fascinating. It's about Henry VIII and the events surrounding his rule in England back around the time when he divorced Catherine of Aragon and married Anne Boelyn. The only downside is that after 10 episodes, they say that a whole new season will be coming out in 2008. So, unless I completely misunderstood them, we won't get to see ANY more of The Tudors until next year.
              I'd like to welcome Aedan Robert Gargrave to the world!
              Born April 17th at 4:10 am...7 lbs, 5 oz, & 20.5" long at birth!


              • #8
                I have to say last night I was disappointed, but not surprised. I would have at least liked to have seen AJ taken out. Was I the only one happy when he was in the pool until Tony dragged him out? Then when his car started smoking I was like finally he's screwed, let down again. God I've never seen anyone whine so much (and was it just me, or did he seriously look like Bud Bundy for the last few episodes?).
                Xenlyn - 80 Gnome DK (Thunderhorn)
                Hobbez Darkpaw - 75 Officer of the Dar Khura (rt)


                • #9
                  Seeing how open the ending is, I wouldn't be surprised they are hoping to do a movie in a few years.


                  • #10
                    So it turned out to be a regular mob story?

                    So Scientology's is correct therapy does not help?


                    • #11
                      Colin Cowherd put it best this morning when he said that "life in the Sopranos universe continued on, it was the audience that got whacked".

                      I really do not think that any other ending would have been quite as good as the one that they had. It just would not have fit in with the rest of the series.
                      Blue Horseshoe loves Anacott Steel


                      • #12
                        An absolutely disappointing ending. This ranks right up there with the Seinfeld ending. They might as well have shown the Sopranos movie teaser at the end of that garbage.

                        I wont be seeing that movie, if/when it comes out. It will only be an attempt to cash in on the fans of the series.


                        • #13
                          is this true?

                          In the "previously on Sopranos" bit in the opening, they made a point to show Bobby and Tony's conversation where he said when you die maybe you don't even see it and everything just goes black.

                          The guy that went into the bathroom was Phil's nephew. He almost definitely came out and blindsided Tony. Probably a nod to the restaurant scene in The Godfather.

                          Meadow had that look on her face because she saw the guy coming up on Tony's side, through the door, but couldn't get there in time to warn him.


                          this was posted on Ayonae Ro - EQ forum board


                          • #14
                            More than one ending...

                            I read somewhere (cant find the link now.. there's just no time, man!) that they shot 4 different endings to the The Sopranos just to keep security tight, and just a hand full of people knew which one was the real one. I would love to see the other 3 if this is the case. I guess it ended the only way it could have. But still, I could have sworn I heard my entire neighborhood screaming "WHAT THE <expletive deleted>!!!" in unison. I had to hit my wife in the head with a pillow to keep her from throwing a water bottle at our TV. I slept on the couch


                            • #15
                              I'd have liked to have seen Sil wake up.. But I guess that's asking too much heh. I liked how they made ya question Paulie, if only a little. The ending was brilliant as well. Big thumbs up from me.